明清易代之际忠贰现象探赜                                      张玉兴  

论历史上满洲与“贰臣”                                        张玉兴 

再谈历史人物评价的几个问题                                    苏双碧 

对传统气节观也应批判的继承                                    王宏志 

论“贰臣”                                                    王宏志 

洪承畴降清考辨                                                李治亭 

再辨洪承畴降清问题                                            李治亭 

关于洪承畴评价的几点思考                                      苏双碧 

论明清之际的“贰臣”                                          李尚英